Film: 2010: "The Good Heart"

The Good Heart

Reviewed by Miv Evans

Rated:  R
Distributor:  MAGNOLIA
Running time:  95 mins
Cast:  Brian Cox (Jacques),  Paul Dano (Lucas), Isild Le Besco (April)
Director/Writer:  Dagur Kari
Producers:  Forensic Films
Release date:  April 30th, 2010
This story is about the bonding of a cynical, mean-spirited old man and a sweet, generous youth who impact so much on each others’ emotions that they both finally become whole.

At least, that’s the story the filmmakers wanted to tell and I know this because the actors recite sign-posted dialogue at every turn.  

Worse still, the characters lurch so erratically from one behavior to another I got a little travel sick about half-way through.   If there had been any kind of conflict I’d have had to run to the bathroom but, as the director/writer thinks drama needs only the token odd flare up, I managed to stay steady.

The Good Heart Movie Trailer

Watch the Official "The Good Heart" movie trailer from Forensic Films through Hulu. Click on the white triangle to start the movie.

The paths of Jacques and Lucas cross in a hospital room, where they both lay damaged by the hand life has dealt them.   Their exchanges are brief and weightless so it is surprising when Jacques seeks out his young friend and moves him into his home, an apartment above his run down New York bar. 

Welcoming a stranger into your home is an extremely kind act but the audience is then fed startlingly contrary information by being shown Jacques’ rude, aggressive behavior to his regular customers.  This  abrupt turn-around is accompanied by a diatribe by Jacques of his Scrooge-like views to an expressionless Lucas.

In case you haven’t quite got the picture, Jacques is Basil Fawlty without the bubbling repression, rapier sarcasm or funny walk and without those all you have is a droning tyrant.  So to counteract the tyrant, Lucas plays the gentle, child-like innocent but to such an extent he becomes a non-personality and drifts through most of the film as a yawn. 

Many of the moments feel staged, one of which is when five men pile into the bar, offer Jacques cash to buy his business, give the grumpy old geezer time to spell out an essential-to-the-plot fact/make a painful attempt at humor, and then they all pile out.  Another is when a French air hostess wafts in, claims to be homeless, acts virtuous one minute and whore-like the next, depending on the dialogue Jacques has to deliver at the time.   Lucas’ character arc is driven by his relationship with this bi-polar mademoiselle but as their super-quick marriage is solely so she can get herself a green card and there is never even a pretense at love, I’m wonder why the writer ever had any hope that that would work.       
There is a very, very big question as to why Jacques decides to ‘adopt’ Lucas in the first place and which  is the entire basis of the film.   The reason we are given is that Jacques wants to keep his legacy alive, but as all he’s got is a crummy New York bar, this motivation doesn’t work at all.  Also, Jacques is on his fifth heart attack, so why is he having his epiphany now?   To make things even more uninteresting, there is a total absence of any back story or insight into any of the characters and all we know about them is what they tell us, so we are never invited in and thus remain uninvolved.

The Good Heart Movie Reviews from Fandango

Click a link to read comments, reviews and ratings posted by Fandango fans. Join the discussion and post your feedback on this film online. Write a movie review and share it with others. Get the latest Fandango sweepstakes and promotional offers. Watch movies trailers of upcoming films.


The errors in this script are lit like Bellisha beacons and even with a comparatively small budget of $4M, it’s hard to understand why the production company didn’t shell out a couple of hundred bucks to get some decent notes. 

Hollywood is knee-deep in script analysts, doctors, editors and any kind of story consultant you want, so why didn’t someone pick up the phone?  Could it be the director/writer had creative control and he decided his script was perfect and he didn’t need notes from anyone?  If so, there is only one response.  Oh dear me.
I’m not going to comment on the directing because it doesn’t really matter, although I suppose if you’re bored enough it does pass the time to study the technicalities.  But if we’re going to do that we might as well go back to silent movies, which might sound like a terrible idea to you, but having just sat through ninety five minutes of drivel I think I’m bound to disagree.

Miv Evans is a British producer now living in Los Angeles


Films in 2010

Film Home Page | Entertainment Magazine

© 2010 Film Entertainment Magazine / All rights reserved.

Film Entertainment Magazine


250x250 Geo Key
Go Fandango!

Buy Fandango Movie Tickets Online

Buy advance tickets to the Toy Story 1 and 2 Double Feature in 3D and get points for posters, DVDs and more!

Buy 1 movie ticket on Fandango and receive a second ticket to the same show free when you use your Visa Signature card.


Blockbuster Total Access - 2 Week Free TrialTry BLOCKBUSTER Total Access FREE! Get the convenience of renting movies online with a choice of how to return them: send them back by mail or exchange them for new movies or discounted game rentals at participating BLOCKBUSTER® stores.

Disney Store

125x125 Disney OutletLinks to online only deals on costumes and entertainment. Outlet store discounts. Save up to 60% on collectibles. See this weeks deals at the Disney Store

Warner Bros. Store

Official Shop of Looney TunesShop at the Warner Bros. Shop :

Toys, games, clothing, posters and more from your favorite Warner Bros. characters like Tweety & Superman and from your favorite WB movies like Harry Potter

RealPlayer Plus

RealPlayer PlusIt's everything people want in a media player including; pristine audio/ video playback, built-in music store, access to worldwide radio.

Receive RealPlayer Plus free with your free 14 day SuperPass trial.

Watch TV Online with SuperPass - 14 Day Free Trial

Hollywood Mega Store

Officially licensed products include celebrities, movies, sports, NASCAR, TV, Marvel, DC Comics and much more. Largest selection of Movie Night & Hollywood Theme Party Supplies, Decor, Favors, and unique items. Very popular Hollywood Trophies. Hollywood and Nostalgic Gift Sets and Gift Baskets. Favored Home Theater Decorations including Reels, Commemoratives, Cinema Lamps and more. Collector items including NECA Action Figures and Head Knockers, Shotglasses, Celebriducks, Tin Signs and Zippo Lighters. Most sought after Posters, Prints and Framed Celebrity Prints. Most popular celebrity, movie and music T-shirts. Hollywood theme T-shirts, Tote Bags and Caps. Very hot JH Design Jackets and Hoodies for men, women, and kids, in all sizes. Celebrity and Novelty License Plates. Rare Vintage License Plates. California Traffic & Street Signs.

MGM Movie Store

Official Shop of MGMShop for all of your MGM favorites at - Rocky, Pink Panther, Stargate, and more! Celebrity and movie clothing, Toys & Games, Jewelry and more from MGM movie titles. Collectibles and Gifts.