Film: 2010: "Paper Man"

Paper Man- flimsy comedy

Rated:  R
Distributor:  MPI Media Group
Producers:  Artfire Films
Running time:  110 mins
Cast:  Jeff Daniels  (Richard),  Emma Stone (Abby), Lisa Kudrow  (Claire)
Directors/Writers:  Michele Mulroney & Kieran Mulroney
Release date:  April 23rd, 2010

This film is billed as a comedy drama about a failed novelist (Richard), his successful wife (Claire), and a troubled 17 year old girl (Amy).  Both the middle-aged novelist and the young girl are in possession of an imaginary friend and it is ostensibly this commonality that brings the two odd balls together, which is where Paper Man takes its fatal dive.  Of the three main characters, the only one powerful enough to keep this humdrum story alive is Lisa Kudrow, but she has comparatively little screen time and, without her, scenes just trundle by on their inevitable journey to DVD Land.

The story is based around Richard’s writers’ block, which has been done so many times it’s a worry before the curtain even goes up.  Why does anyone think we want to watch an actor procrastinating in front of a blank screen?  

This is about as interesting as watching a woman give birth, but at least with the latter you know you’re guaranteed an outcome.  And why Claire wants Richard to write, and why Richard wants to write, is a complete mystery. 

He’s well into his fifties, has had one book published which didn’t sell a single copy, and now he can’t write another word. 

We are never told what he’s done with the rest of his working life but if it took him thirty years to produce the first disaster I’m not surprised progress is rather slow.

Another reason to switch roles and make Claire the one to befriend the teenager would be to avoid that uneasy feeling when a young girl and a man old enough to be her grandfather get together.  I know, I know, one shouldn’t automatically assume because he’s a guy he’s going to be tempted by young flesh and embarrass himself and her by hitting on his young victim, but there’s always that outside chance, isn’t there?

Paper Man Movie Reviews from Fandango

Click a link to read comments, reviews and ratings posted by Fandango fans. Join the discussion and post your feedback on this film online. Write a movie review and share it with others. Get the latest Fandango sweepstakes and promotional offers. Watch movies trailers of upcoming films.

Loading...

In the same vein, if the roles had been reversed, we would have expected the young guy to want to have sex with the older woman, which isn’t necessarily what you want to see but at least the thought isn’t quite so disgusting.  And in case you’re wondering, Richard got drunk to make his play and denied it the next day, but once sex is on the table whatever other kind of connection you get seems like second prize.      

And now we have to deal with the imaginary friends.   Abby’s is a boy her age and for most of the time it appears he’s real which stops us from thinking that she’s completely alone and as she shows him little sympathy we have less for her.   Richard’s, on the other hand, is dressed like superman and is so incongruous an explanation is needed but never given. 

These celestial beings are never integrated into the story and, as conduits for the characters’ internal dialogue, are vastly underused.  The goal for both Richard and Abby could have been to get rid of the specter in their head but instead this exorcism is more a side effect and the only one with a clear goal is Clare, who wants her old man to get his act together.

What always baffles me when I watch films like this is why they’re billed as ‘comedy’ drama.  Perhaps the appearance of Superman is supposed to be funny, and there were a few other equally bizarre moments but I honestly don’t remember anyone rolling in the aisles.    Equally baffling is the filmmakers’ claim that the message in this film is about growing up, but Abby doesn’t seem particularly immature for a 17 year old and Richard doesn’t seem particularly childish; his wife cutting up his food and feeding him means that she needs to change, not him. 

So the only message I got left with is that if you’re a writer, and the best you can come up with is an idea about a writer who has writers’ block, trust me, as ideas go, you’re clean out of them.


Miv Evans is a British producer now living in Los Angeles

 

Films in 2010

Film Home Page | Entertainment Magazine

© 2010 Film Entertainment Magazine / EMOL.org. All rights reserved.

Film Entertainment Magazine

MOVIE RENTAL DEALS

250x250 Geo Key
Go Fandango!

Buy Fandango Movie Tickets Online

Buy advance tickets to the Toy Story 1 and 2 Double Feature in 3D and get points for posters, DVDs and more!

Buy 1 movie ticket on Fandango and receive a second ticket to the same show free when you use your Visa Signature card.

Blockbuster

Blockbuster Total Access - 2 Week Free TrialTry BLOCKBUSTER Total Access FREE! Get the convenience of renting movies online with a choice of how to return them: send them back by mail or exchange them for new movies or discounted game rentals at participating BLOCKBUSTER® stores.

Disney Store

125x125 Disney OutletLinks to online only deals on costumes and entertainment. Outlet store discounts. Save up to 60% on collectibles. See this weeks deals at the Disney Store

Warner Bros. Store

Official Shop of Looney TunesShop at the Warner Bros. Shop : WBShop.com

Toys, games, clothing, posters and more from your favorite Warner Bros. characters like Tweety & Superman and from your favorite WB movies like Harry Potter

RealPlayer Plus

RealPlayer PlusIt's everything people want in a media player including; pristine audio/ video playback, built-in music store, access to worldwide radio.

Receive RealPlayer Plus free with your free 14 day SuperPass trial.

Watch TV Online with SuperPass - 14 Day Free Trial

Hollywood Mega Store

Officially licensed products include celebrities, movies, sports, NASCAR, TV, Marvel, DC Comics and much more. Largest selection of Movie Night & Hollywood Theme Party Supplies, Decor, Favors, and unique items. Very popular Hollywood Trophies. Hollywood and Nostalgic Gift Sets and Gift Baskets. Favored Home Theater Decorations including Reels, Commemoratives, Cinema Lamps and more. Collector items including NECA Action Figures and Head Knockers, Shotglasses, Celebriducks, Tin Signs and Zippo Lighters. Most sought after Posters, Prints and Framed Celebrity Prints. Most popular celebrity, movie and music T-shirts. Hollywood theme T-shirts, Tote Bags and Caps. Very hot JH Design Jackets and Hoodies for men, women, and kids, in all sizes. Celebrity and Novelty License Plates. Rare Vintage License Plates. California Traffic & Street Signs.

MGM Movie Store

Official Shop of MGMShop for all of your MGM favorites at MGMStore.com - Rocky, Pink Panther, Stargate, and more! Celebrity and movie clothing, Toys & Games, Jewelry and more from MGM movie titles. Collectibles and Gifts.